“The beauty of life is, while we cannot undo what is done, we can see it, understand it, learn from it, and change so that every new moment is spent not in regret, guilt, fear, or anger, but in wisdom, understanding, and love.”

- Jennifer Edwards

Welcome to our family support group for loved ones in recovery! This week, we discussed the difference between shame and guilt. Shame involves having a negative perception of oneself, leading someone to believe they are inherently flawed or undeserving of happiness. This feeling often arises when individuals don't measure up to their ideals. In contrast, guilt is associated with a sense of responsibility or regret over one's actions or inactions. People typically feel guilt when they think they have done something wrong or caused harm, but it can also stem from situations beyond their control. Often, family members experience feelings of shame and guilt around their loved one's addiction. Shame and guilt can sound like, “I feel both guilty and ashamed because I think I should have been able to prevent this. I can't help but feel responsible for their addiction”, or “I feel guilty for not being able to help them recover and ashamed because I feel helpless. It's hard to admit that I can't fix this.” These feelings are normal responses to families' challenges, and there are unhealthy and healthy ways to cope with these feelings. Looking inside ourselves and sharing these feelings with others takes strength and vulnerability, and they are also part of the healing process for yourself, your family, and your loved one.

Definition and Differences:

Shame: Shame is a pervasive feeling that something is fundamentally wrong with us. It is an internalized sense of being unworthy or flawed. Shame affects our self-identity rather than just our actions.

  • Example: “I feel ashamed because I think I must be a bad parent/sibling/partner for having a loved one with an addiction.”

Guilt: Guilt arises when we feel we have done something wrong or failed to live up to our own or others’ expectations. It is focused on our actions and their consequences. For example, a family member might feel guilty for not recognizing the signs of addiction earlier.

  • Example: “I feel guilty because I didn’t notice my loved one was struggling with addiction sooner.”

Examples of Shame:

  • Stigma and Judgment:
    • Example: “I feel ashamed because people in our community know about my loved one’s addiction. I worry about what they think of our family.”
  • Self-Identity:
    • Example: “I feel ashamed because I think having a loved one with an addiction means I failed as a parent/partner/sibling. It makes me question my worth.”
  • Social Isolation:
    • Example: “I avoid social gatherings because I’m ashamed to admit that my loved one is struggling with addiction. I don’t want to face the questions and judgment.”
  • Impact on Family Dynamics:
    • Example: “I feel ashamed of how addiction has affected our family relationships. It feels like we’re falling apart, and I don’t know how to fix it.”

Examples of Guilt:

  • Not Recognizing the Signs:
    • Example: “I feel guilty because I didn’t notice my loved one was struggling with addiction sooner. Maybe if I had, I could have helped them before it got worse.”
  • Enabling Behavior:
    • Example: “I feel guilty because I gave my loved one money, even though I suspected it might be used for drugs. I thought I was helping, but I might have made things worse.”
  • Not Being There:
    • Example: “I feel guilty for not being around enough due to my work commitments. I wonder if my absence contributed to their substance use.”
  • Past Conflicts:
    • Example: “I feel guilty about the arguments and harsh words we had before I knew about their addiction. I regret not being more understanding.”

Combined Feelings of Shame and Guilt:

  • Blaming Themselves:
    • Example: “I feel both guilty and ashamed because I think I should have been able to prevent this. I can’t help but feel responsible for their addiction.”
  • Inability to Help:
    • Example: “I feel guilty for not being able to help them recover and ashamed because I feel helpless. It’s hard to admit that I can’t fix this.”

How Addiction Exacerbates These Feelings:

  • Cycle of Enabling:
    • Example: “I feel guilty for enabling their addiction and ashamed every time I do it. I feel trapped in a cycle I don’t know how to break.”
  • Negative Self-Perception:
    • Example: “Each time my loved one relapses, I feel a renewed sense of guilt and shame. It reinforces the belief that I’m not doing enough.”

Recognizing and addressing these feelings of guilt and shame is crucial for the emotional well-being of family members. It’s important to remember that these emotions are common and understandable, and seeking support can help manage them effectively.

Impact of shame and guilt:

Impact on Family Members:

Shame can lead to profound feelings of inadequacy and self-disapproval, while guilt can result in persistent emotions of regret, sadness, and anxiety. These feelings can significantly impact us emotionally, mentally, and behaviorally.

Emotional Impact:

  • Shame can lead to profound feelings of inadequacy and self-doubt, causing family members to withdraw from social interactions due to fear of judgment. This emotional burden can be incredibly isolating.
  • Guilt can bring about persistent feelings of regret, sadness, and anxiety. Family members might repeatedly reflect on past situations, wondering what they could have done differently, which can be mentally and emotionally exhausting.

Mental Impact:

  • Shame can impact self-esteem and lead to chronic stress. It may also cause distorted self-perceptions and a negative view of the world.
  • Guilt can be all-consuming, with family members frequently replaying past mistakes in their minds. This constant rumination can significantly contribute to feelings of depression and anxiety, making it difficult to find peace and move forward.

Behavioral Impact:

  • Shame can cause avoidance behaviors, such as isolating themselves from others or not seeking help, as they may feel undeserving of support or change.
  • Guilt can drive family members to overcompensate by trying to “fix” everything, leading to burnout and frustration when their efforts do not seem to work.

Connection to Addiction

Addiction can magnify feelings of guilt and shame. Family members may feel guilty for enabling their loved one’s addiction or not preventing it. Meanwhile, the person with addiction may feel deep shame about their behavior, which can hinder their willingness to seek help.

Addiction and Shame:

  • Family members might feel ashamed of their association with addiction, fearing judgment and stigma from their community. This shame can prevent them from seeking support or talking openly about their struggles.
  • The person with addiction often feels deep shame about their behavior, which can hinder their willingness to seek help or believe in the possibility of recovery.

Addiction and Guilt:

  • Family members might struggle with feelings of shame about their association with addiction, fearing judgment and stigma from their community. This heavy burden of shame can make it incredibly difficult for them to seek support or openly discuss their challenges.
  • For the person battling addiction, the profound shame they feel about their behavior can become a significant barrier, making it hard to reach out for help or believe in the possibility of recovery.

Exacerbation by Addiction:

  • Addiction can intensify feelings of guilt and shame for both the individual and their family members, amplifying the emotional pain experienced by everyone involved. The chaos and unpredictability that often accompany addiction can lead to numerous situations that trigger these painful emotions.
  • As the individual turns to substances to cope with their guilt and shame, these feelings often deepen, creating a harmful cycle that impacts the entire family. This destructive loop makes it even harder for everyone to find a way out and heal.

Healthy Coping Mechanisms

Grounding Techniques:

Grounding exercises, such as the 5-4-3-2-1 technique (naming 5 things you can see, 4 things you can touch, 3 things you can hear, 2 things you can smell, and 1 thing you can taste), can help you stay present.

Self-Compassion

Self-compassion involves treating yourself with the same kindness, understanding, and care you would offer a good friend. It means recognizing that everyone makes mistakes and that imperfections are a natural part of being human.

Activities:

  • Self-Compassionate Statements: Write and repeat positive affirmations or compassionate statements to yourself. Examples include, “I am doing the best I can,” or “It’s okay to make mistakes. I can learn and grow from them.”
  • Journaling: Keep a self-compassion journal where you can reflect on moments of self-criticism and reframe them with self-kindness and understanding.
  • Compassionate Letter: Write a letter to yourself from the perspective of a compassionate friend, acknowledging your struggles and offering encouragement and support.

Seeking Support

Seeking support involves reaching out to others for emotional and practical assistance. This can include joining support groups, seeking therapy or counseling, and talking to trusted friends or family members.

Activities:

  • Support Groups: Support groups can benefit you and your family. They can provide a safe space to share experiences, gain insights, and receive emotional support.
  • Therapy or Counseling: Seeking professional help can benefit you and your family. Therapy can offer tools and strategies to manage guilt and shame and provide a space for personal growth and healing.
  • Building a Support Network: Identifying and reaching out to supportive friends and family members who can offer a listening ear and empathy can be very valuable.

Mindfulness and Relaxation

Mindfulness involves paying attention to the present moment openly and without judgment. Relaxation techniques help reduce stress and promote a sense of calm and well-being.

Activities:

Mindfulness meditation is a practice that involves focusing your mind on the present moment. It helps to increase awareness of your thoughts, feelings, and sensations without judgment. This practice can reduce stress, improve emotional well-being, and enhance mental clarity.

Simple Mindfulness Meditation Practices:

  • Focusing on the Breath:
    • Find a Comfortable Position: Sit or lie down in a comfortable position. Ensure your back is straight and you feel relaxed.
    • Close Your Eyes: Gently close your eyes to minimize distractions.
    • Breathe Naturally: Focus on your natural breathing pattern. Notice the sensation of air entering and leaving your nostrils or the rise and fall of your chest.
    • Observe Without Judgment: If your mind starts to wander, gently bring your focus back to your breath. Observe your thoughts without judging or analyzing them.
    • Duration: Start with 5 minutes and gradually increase the time as you become more comfortable with the practice.
  • Observing Thoughts and Feelings:
    • Find a Quiet Space: Choose a quiet place where you won’t be disturbed.
    • Sit Comfortably: Sit comfortably with your back straight and your hands resting on your lap.
    • Focus Inward: Close your eyes and take a few deep breaths to center yourself.
    • Watch Your Thoughts: Imagine your thoughts and feelings as clouds pass by in the sky. Observe them without getting caught up in them. Just let them come and go.
    • Non-Judgmental Awareness: Acknowledge each thought and feeling with curiosity and without judgment. If a thought is particularly persistent, gently redirect your focus back to your breath.
    • Duration: Practice for about 5 minutes, gradually increasing as you feel more comfortable.
  • Body Scan Meditation:
    • Lie Down or Sit Comfortably: Lie on your back with your arms relaxed by your sides, or sit comfortably with your feet flat on the ground.
    • Close Your Eyes: Close your eyes and take a few deep breaths.
    • Focus on Different Parts of Your Body: Starting from your toes, gradually move your attention upward through each body part. Notice any sensations, tension, or areas of relaxation.
      • Toes and Feet: Feel the sensations in your toes and feet. Tense the muscles for a few seconds, then release.
      • Legs: Move your focus to your calves and thighs. Tense the muscles, then relax.
      • Stomach and Chest: Notice any sensations in your stomach and chest. Take a deep breath, and as you exhale, release any tension.
      • Arms and Hands: Focus on your arms and hands, tensing and then relaxing the muscles.
      • Neck and Shoulders: Pay attention to your neck and shoulders. Shrug your shoulders up to your ears, hold for a few seconds, and then release.
      • Face and Head: Finally, focus on your face and head. Notice any tension in your forehead, eyes, or jaw. Gently relax each area.
      • Complete the Scan: Once you’ve scanned your entire body, take a few more deep breaths and gradually bring your awareness back to the present moment.
      • Duration: This practice can take you about 20-30 minutes. During this time, allow yourself to fully relax and tune into your body.
  • Mindful Walking: Mindful walking involves paying close attention to the walking experience, making it a meditative practice.
    • Focus on Sensations: As you walk, notice the sensations in your feet and legs. Feel the ground beneath you and the movement of your muscles.
    • Breath Awareness: Synchronize your breathing with your steps. For example, you might inhale for three steps and exhale for three steps.
    • Environmental Observation: Take in your surroundings. Notice the colors, sounds, and smells around you without getting lost in thoughts.
    • Presence: Be fully present in each step, letting go of distractions and bringing your mind back to the act of walking if it wanders.
  • Mindful Eating: Mindful eating encourages you to experience your food and the act of eating fully.
    • Slow Down: Eat slowly, savoring each bite. Notice the texture, taste, and aroma of your food.
    • Gratitude: Take a moment to appreciate where your food came from and the effort that went into preparing it.
    • Engage Your Senses: Before taking a bite, pay attention to the colors, shapes, and smells of your food.
    • Chewing: Chew thoroughly and notice how the food changes in your mouth. Experience each bite fully without rushing through the meal.
  • Mindful Art: Engaging in art mindfully allows you to be fully immersed in the creative process.
    • Set an Intention: Start with a clear intention to be present and enjoy creating without judging the outcome.
    • Focus on the Process: Pay attention to the sensation of the brush on the canvas, the color blending, or the movement of your hands.
    • Let Go of Perfection: Embrace creating rather than focusing on the final product. Allow yourself to make mistakes and see where your creativity takes you.
    • Sensory Engagement: Notice the textures, smells, and sounds involved in your artistic process. Fully immerse yourself in the experience.

 

Related Resources

Our Articles

Media

12 Essential Insights for Emotional Sobriety: Getting Your Recovery Unstuck
 in Books
Addict in the House: A No-Nonsense Family Guide Through Addiction and Recovery
 in Books
Am I helping, or enabling?
 in Documents
Anger Iceberg
 in Documents
Detachment
 in Documents
Coping With Early Recovery
 in Documents
Resentment…..The Pain that Keeps on Giving
 in Documents
Stigma of Addiction
 in Watch
The Disease of Addiction
 in Documents
The Cycle of Guilt and Shame
 in Documents
Working Through Shame and Guilt
 in Documents

Web

Al-Anon Family Groups
Co-Dependents Anonymous (CoDA)
Hazelden Betty Ford Foundation
Helping Families Help – CRAFT Groups
Hopestream Community
National Association for Children of Alcoholics
PAL: Parents of Addicted Loved Ones
SMART Recovery for Marijuana Addiction